St. Louis County Is a “No-Refusal” County. Should You Still Refuse a Breath Test?

St. Louis County DWI lawyer John Schleiffarth

By John C. Schleiffarth, St. Louis DWI and criminal defense attorney

In November 2025, the St. Louis County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office announced that St. Louis County is now a “no-refusal” county for DWI arrests. Since then, many people have asked us whether refusing a breath test is still allowed, and whether it still makes sense.

The short answer: refusing is still legal in Missouri, and for many first-time DWI arrests in St. Louis County, it can still be the better choice. Here’s what the policy actually does, and what you need to know if you were stopped for suspicion of DWI.

What “no-refusal” means in St. Louis County

Under Missouri’s implied consent law, anyone who drives in Missouri is considered to have agreed to a chemical test of their breath, blood, saliva, or urine if they’re arrested for DWI. You can still say no. If you do, the officer can’t force a breath test on you.

What changed in St. Louis County is the following: if you refuse, an on-call prosecutor is available to help the officer apply to a judge for a search warrant for your blood. If a judge signs it, your blood can be drawn without your consent.

A “no-refusal” policy doesn’t make refusing illegal. It means the police may try to get the evidence another way by seeking a warrant to draw your blood.

Why police need a warrant to draw your blood

The warrant requirement comes from a Missouri case. In Missouri v. McNeely (2013), a driver stopped in Cape Girardeau County refused a breath test, and a trooper had his blood drawn at a hospital without a warrant. The U.S. Supreme Court ruled that in a routine DWI case, police generally need a warrant before taking a blood sample without consent. The fact that alcohol leaves the body over time isn’t enough, on its own, to skip that step.

A breath test is different. Police don’t need a warrant to ask for one after an arrest, but you can still refuse it under Missouri law.

What happens after a refusal

In practice, “no-refusal” doesn’t mean every refusal ends in a blood draw. The officer has to make a judgment call. Getting blood means applying for a warrant, waiting for a judge, and then either taking you back to the station for an EMT to draw blood or, more often, taking you to a hospital and waiting while a nurse draws the sample. That takes time. That time can be critical if you are sobering up. Reverse extrapolating your estimated blood alcohol concentration is difficult for the prosecution. They usually do not even try.

It is often faster and more practical for an officer to write you up as a refusal and get back on the road to make more arrests. That’s why many refusals in St. Louis County still never lead to a blood test. It should also be taken into account that St. Louis County has numerous municipal police forces that may have differing policies.

What refusing costs you

Refusing has consequences, and you should know them before you decide:

  • A one-year license revocation. A refusal triggers an automatic one-year revocation by the Department of Revenue. You get a 15-day temporary permit. To fight the revocation, you have 30 days to file a petition for review in the circuit court of the county where you were arrested, but the permit runs out after 15 days. The best thing to do is to hire an attorney to file the petition for review early and ask the court for a stay order so you can keep driving while the case is pending.
  • The refusal can be used against you. Under Missouri law, evidence that you refused a test can be used in your criminal case. Prosecutors may argue you refused because you knew you would fail. We can often rebut those arguments effectively, but it will be a tactic of the prosecution.
  • You have 20 minutes to call a lawyer. If you ask to speak with an attorney before deciding, Missouri law gives you 20 minutes to try to reach one. If you still refuse after that, it counts as a refusal. Here’s a pro tip: for some people, requesting to contact a lawyer can also be a strategic choice if they feel they might be close to the legal limit and plan to complete a breath test. That extra 20 minutes might give them just enough time to drop below the legal limit.

Our advice for a first-offense DWI in St. Louis County

Our general advice hasn’t changed: for a first-offense DWI in St. Louis County, if you have any doubt about your sobriety, it is usually better to refuse the breath test and let us fight your case in court than to hand the police more evidence. That being said, we always recommend that you contact an attorney to get specific advice for your specific situation.

Warrants take time, and that time can be precious to police officers who are trying to get intoxicated drivers off the road. Don’t be intimidated into taking a breath test if you don’t feel comfortable. Unless they have a warrant, you always have a choice. In my experience, not everyone who refuses ends up at the hospital getting a blood test. Police officers frequently use Mercy and BJC, but a few departments have their own trained EMTs that are licensed to draw blood.

The one-year revocation is serious, but it can be challenged, and a breath result over the legal limit is often the hardest evidence to overcome. Every situation is different, though. Prior offenses, a commercial driver’s license, or an accident with injuries can change the math. If you can reach us during the 20-minute window, call us at 314-561-9690.

If the police got a warrant and drew your blood

Blood evidence can be challenged too. In these cases, we look closely at:

  • The warrant itself. Did the officer’s sworn application actually show probable cause, and was the warrant properly issued?
  • Timing. How long passed between driving and the blood draw? Alcohol levels rise and fall over time, so a delayed sample may not reflect your level at the time you were driving.
  • Who drew the blood. Missouri limits who may draw blood for a DWI test. A draw by someone without the required qualifications can be challenged.
  • Handling and testing. How the sample was labeled, stored, transported, and tested at the lab, and whether the chain of custody holds up.

Learn more about BAC testing defenses.

What to do now

  1. Find your paperwork. Look for your notice of revocation or suspension, your ticket or summons, and any warrant or hospital paperwork. Note your arrest date.
  2. Watch the deadlines. Your temporary permit lasts 15 days. If you refused, the petition for review should be filed before it runs out.
  3. Write down what happened. Include when you were stopped, whether you asked for a lawyer, how long you waited, and whether you were taken to a station or hospital.
  4. Don’t discuss your case with anyone but your attorney, and don’t post about it online.
  5. Call a DWI lawyer. See our guide to what to do in the first 15 days after a DWI arrest and our page on DWI and your driver’s license.

Talk to a St. Louis County DWI lawyer

JCS Law has handled more than 2,000 DWI cases across St. Louis, St. Louis County, St. Charles County, and surrounding Missouri counties. Learn more about our St. Louis DWI defense practice.

Call 314-561-9690 or contact us online for a free consultation in person, by phone, or by video. We accept credit cards and offer flexible payment terms.

No-refusal DWI questions: St. Louis County and Missouri

Is it illegal to refuse a breathalyzer in Missouri?

No. You can refuse a chemical test after a DWI arrest. A refusal leads to a one-year license revocation, which can be challenged, and the refusal can be used as evidence in your criminal case.

Can police force a blood test in St. Louis County?

Only with a search warrant signed by a judge, or in rare emergencies. Under the no-refusal policy, an on-call prosecutor helps officers apply for a warrant after a refusal, but officers don’t seek one in every case.

Can I talk to a lawyer before deciding whether to take the test?

Yes. If you ask, Missouri law gives you 20 minutes to try to reach an attorney. If you still refuse after that, it’s treated as a refusal.

How long do I have to fight a refusal revocation?

You have 30 days to file a petition for review in circuit court, but your temporary permit lasts only 15 days. File early and ask for a stay so you can keep driving.

Can a blood test result be challenged?

Yes. Common issues include whether the warrant was valid, how much time passed before the draw, who drew the blood, and how the sample was stored and tested.

Should I refuse a breath test in St. Louis County?

It depends on your situation. For many first-offense DWIs, refusing and fighting the case in court is the better choice when there’s any doubt about sobriety. Prior offenses, a CDL, or an accident can change that. Call us at 314-561-9690.

Return to Blog

If you have any questions call: 314-561-9690